Money and Finance

Hussman Weekly Market Comment: Short Horizon, Long Horizon

Over history, and including the past decade, properly normalized valuations have remained a powerful guidepost for full-cycle and long-term returns, particularly on the horizon of 7-10 years. On that front, the current price/revenue multiple of the S&P 500 of 1.54 is now nearly double the historical norm prior to the late-1990’s bubble. The same is true for other useful metrics such as the market value of nonfinancial stocks to nominal GDP (based on Z.1 flow of funds data). With our broadest estimate of prospective S&P 500 10-year nominal total returns down to just 2.9% annually, 10-year Treasury bond yields at 2.7%, Treasury bill yields pinned at zero, and state and corporate pension assumptions still in the range of 7-8% annually, it appears quite likely that the coming decade will produce a widespread pension funding crisis in the U.S.

Meanwhile, the current Shiller P/E (S&P 500 divided by the 10-year average of inflation-adjusted earnings) of 24.2 is closer to 65% above its pre-bubble median. Despite the 10-year averaging, Shiller earnings – the denominator of the Shiller P/E – are currently 6.4% of S&P 500 revenues, compared to a pre-bubble norm of only about 5.4%. So contrary to the assertion that Shiller earnings are somehow understated due to the brief plunge in earnings during the credit crisis, the opposite is actually true. If anything, Shiller earnings have benefited from recently elevated margins, and the Shiller P/E presently understates the extent of market overvaluation. On historically normal profit margins, the Shiller P/E would be about 29 here. In any event, on the basis of valuation measures that are actually well-correlated with subsequent market returns, current valuations are now at or beyond the most extreme points in a century of market history, save for the final approach to the 2000 peak.

Of course, valuations exert far more effect on long-term returns than on short-term outcomes, where a much larger set of considerations generally apply. Unfortunately, on shorter horizons, the past few years have been unusual. Market conditions that have historically resulted in awful losses over the intermediate-term have instead been associated with positive returns.

- Links
Mohnish Pabrai, Guy Spier, and Michael Shearn on Investment Checklists [H/T ValueWalk... This is the video and transcript from their Value Conferences appearance early in 2014.] (LINK) Related book: The Investment ChecklistRichard Muller's Physics...

- Links
Q&A with Guy Spier about his book, The Education of a Value Investor (LINK) Buffett’s Private Analysis of Geico in 1976: ‘Extraordinary’ But ‘Mismanaged’ [H/T Lincoln] (LINK) Aswath Damodaran on corporate break-ups, using EBay and PayPal...

- Hussman Weekly Market Comment: Exit Strategy
Link to: Exit Strategy The S&P 500 set a marginal new high on Friday, in the context of a broad rollover in momentum thus far this year that we view as likely – though of course not certain – to represent a broad cyclical peak of the sort that...

- Hussman Weekly Market Comment: Increasing Concerns And Systemic Instability
Link to: Increasing Concerns and Systemic Instability With the S&P 500 just 3% below its all-time high, there’s very little change our views here. Last week’s mild retreat only looks something other than mild when viewed in the context of a late-stage...

- Hussman Weekly Market Comment: Did Monetary Policy Cause The Recovery?
As investors, we should be aware that the current Shiller P/E of 24.8 (S&P 500 divided by the 10-year average of inflation adjusted earnings) is now above every historical instance prior to the bubble period since the late-1990's, save for the...

Money and Finance