Hussman Weekly Market Comment: Bayes' Rule (January 29, 2007)
Fun with Bayes' Rule: Birds and Hamsters
Suppose that you've got a truckload of animals in boxes, but you can't actually see the animals. If the animal is a hamster, there's an 80% chance the box is green. If it's a bird, there's only a 20% chance the box is green. You're given a green box. How likely is it that the animal inside is a hamster?
Though it's tempting to answer that a hamster is most likely, we need more information. We have to know what proportion of the animals are hamsters.
Suppose that only 10% are hamsters. Then given it's a hamster (10%) there's an 80% chance the box is green. So 10% x 80% = 8% of the time we'll have a hamster and a green box. However, we'll also have a green box in 20% of the cases where the animal is a bird (90% of the animals). So 20% x 90% = 18% of the time we'll have a bird and a green box.
Bayes Rule says that the probability it's a hamster when you're handed a green box is:
8% / (8% + 18%) = 31%.
Most likely, there's a bird in the green box. Notice that choosing a green box increases the probability it's a hamster (which you would expect just 10% of the time if you had no information about the box), but it's not enough to make a hamster the most likely expectation.
- “this Bird Thinks!”
A BIG thanks to Peter for passing this story/excerpt along. From the book Fear of Physics by Lawrence Krauss:No two physicists could have been more different than Dirac and Feynman. As much as Feynman was an extrovert, so much was Dirac and introvert....
- An Inside Look At David Einhorn's "big Short"
Hedge fund manager David Einhorn is taking an even harder line against Green Mountain Coffee Roasters (GMCR.O), his big short trade, claiming a recent audit committee review of the accounting issues he flagged is nothing more than a "whitewash." In an...
- John Allen Paulos Reviews "the Theory That Would Not Die" By Sharon Bertsch Mcgrayne
Sharon Bertsch McGrayne introduces Bayes’s theorem in her new book with a remark by John Maynard Keynes: “When the facts change, I change my opinion. What do you do, sir?” Bayes’s theorem, named after the 18th-century Presbyterian minister Thomas...
- The Absolute Return Letter - September 2009: The Hamster On The Wheel – By Niels C. Jensen
It is not universally appreciated, but the last 25-30 years have, in general, been staggeringly good to most investors. Technology induced productivity enhancements combined with favourable demographic trends, minimal government involvement, accommodating...
- Weekly Roundup - April 19, 2014
One of my favorite parts about spring here in Texas is getting to see all of the wildflowers blooming. Our state flower is the Texas Bluebonnet and for good reason too, those things pop up everywhere. We even have some in our backyard at our new...