Money and Finance

Clayton Christensen Responds to New Yorker Takedown of 'Disruptive Innovation'

The article he's responding to was the one I had linked to yesterday, HERE.

Link to: Clayton Christensen Responds to New Yorker Takedown of 'Disruptive Innovation'

When the New Yorker this week published Harvard historian Jill Lepore’s sharply written dismissal of “disruptive innovation,” it was an attack on one of the most widely cited and celebrated ideas in modern business. As first laid out by its creator, Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen, in his 1997 book, The Innovator’s Dilemma, the theory holds that established companies, acting rationally and carefully to stay on top, leave themselves vulnerable to upstarts who find ways to do things more cheaply, often with a new technology. The book became a bestseller in 1999, at the height of the dot-com boom, as it seemed to describe the threat e-commerce posed to established companies. Christensen expanded on it in a series of sequels, including The Innovator’s Solution, The Innovator’s Prescription, about health care, and Disrupting Class, about education.

Disruption, as Lepore notes, has since become an all-purpose rallying cry, not only in Silicon Valley—though especially there—but in boardrooms everywhere. “It’s a theory of history founded on a profound anxiety about financial collapse, an apocalyptic fear of global devastation, and shaky evidence,” she writes. In the article, she accuses Christensen of poor scholarship (handpicking case studies that conform to his theory); misreading history (some companies he casts as doomed continued to perform well); and myopia (missing, for example, the role unions played in the collapse of U.S. Steel). Lepore also notes that a fund manager who used Christensen’s theory as an investment strategy lost even more than most in the Nasdaq implosion of 2000.

Christensen hasn’t responded in writing to the essay, but when I reached him by phone on Thursday afternoon, it was clear he’d been thinking about it. Consistently described by those who know him as a generous and thoughtful and upbeat person, he is also capable of fury. “Keep asking me questions,” he said, “it’s helping me.”

...............

For a list of Christensen's books, go HERE.

- The Disruption Machine: What The Gospel Of Innovation Gets Wrong. – By Jill Lepore
UPDATE: Clayton Christensen responded to this article, HERE. Link to article: THE DISRUPTION MACHINEPorter was interested in how companies succeed. The scholar who in some respects became his successor, Clayton M. Christensen, entered a doctoral program...

- Clayton Christensen Wants To Transform Capitalism
Sixteen years ago a book by Clayton Christensen changed business thinking forever. The Innovator’s Dilemma looked at industries ranging from disk drives to steel to mechanical excavators and exposed a surprising phenomenon: When big companies fail,...

- Clay Christensen's Life Lessons
Thanks to Will for passing this along. On a warm April evening, Clayton Christensen arrived at his home in Belmont, Mass., desperate for a peanut butter sandwich. Christensen is diabetic, and with his blood sugar low, he seemed out of sorts. As he crushed...

- Clayton M. Christensen On Disruptive Innovation In Health Care
Interview: Disruptive Innovation: Can Health Care Learn From Other Industries? A Conversation With Clayton M. ChristensenArticle: Disruptive Innovation In Health Care Delivery: A Framework For Business-Model Innovation – By Jason Hwang and Clayton M....

- When Capitalism And Corporate Self-interest Collide - By John Kay
Adam Smith understood the difference between policies that favoured free trade and policies that favoured established business. “The interest of the dealers in any particular branch of trade or manufacturers,” he wrote, “is always in some respects...

Money and Finance